Note that this thread was started 1768 days ago and might not be up-to-date anymore. Please consider creating a new thread before posting.
Page 1 of 2 12 Last
  • Jump to page:
Results 1 to 25 of 30

Thread: Japanese age of consent (misinterpreted fact or blatant lie?)

  1. #1
    Rope Shrine Maiden Female
    Join Date Mar 5, 2007
    Location England
    Posts 1,570
    UK - England

    Japanese age of consent (misinterpreted fact or blatant lie?)


    国際交流パーティー
    Tokyo International Party

    I just found an article detailing the 10 stupidest British Laws.

    Underneath, there was a section detailling the 10 stupidest foreign laws.

    Number 9 on this list claims that there is no age of consent in Japan. However, further research has told me that the age of consent is 13 and, in some prefectures, 16. I was wondering how people felt about this comment. Is it just a "fact" that the writers didn't think to look into, or is it a blatent lie to further the stereotype of Japan as an extremely perverted nation?

    Here is a link to the original article, Ten stupidest laws are named - Telegraph.co.uk
  2. #2
    Japa'n vagyok Female
    Join Date Jan 18, 2006
    Location Nowhere - Now here
    Posts 3,541
    Japan-Tokyo
    We do have age of consent here in Japan, its 16 years old for female and 18 years old for male.
    It is the same anywhere in Japan.
    (And of course, even one reached the age of consent, she/he still needs approval of her/his parents for marriage as long as they are minors, i.e. less than 20 years old.)

    I'm appalled to see it's an article from a newspaper.
    Don't they ever make any research before publishing an article???
    *I love undrentide by Mediaeval Baebes*
    And here're my bloggies (JP) & (HU)
  3. #3
    Rope Shrine Maiden Female
    Join Date Mar 5, 2007
    Location England
    Posts 1,570
    UK - England
    You would think they would, but some newspapers just publish what people have heard and report it as news when it strictly isn't true. This can be seen in recent articles where newspapers (The Sun mostly) published a story saying that Simon Cowell would cancell the X-Factor if John and Edward survived another week. Dermot O'Leary then published in his own column that this had never been said.

    The article was form 2008, so it might be reasonable to assume Japanese laws have changed in a year, but I refuse to believe there was no age of consent, and I can't believe the paper published it.

    Like I said though, in other countries we have this stereotype of Japan being a perverted nation, full of love-hotels, realistic sex-dolls and the used underwear of school-girls being available in vending machines, and I was wondering if you think that this article was just a lie to further this stereotype or did the writer just not do the research before publishing public opinion?
  4. #4
    先輩 Male
    Join Date Dec 5, 2007
    Location Tokyo, born in Kyoto
    Posts 1,264
    Japan-Tokyo
    You would think they would, but some newspapers just publish what people have heard and report it as news when it strictly isn't true. This can be seen in recent articles where newspapers (The Sun mostly) published a story saying that Simon Cowell would cancell the X-Factor if John and Edward survived another week. Dermot O'Leary then published in his own column that this had never been said.

    The article was form 2008, so it might be reasonable to assume Japanese laws have changed in a year, but I refuse to believe there was no age of consent, and I can't believe the paper published it.

    Like I said though, in other countries we have this stereotype of Japan being a perverted nation, full of love-hotels, realistic sex-dolls and the used underwear of school-girls being available in vending machines, and I was wondering if you think that this article was just a lie to further this stereotype or did the writer just not do the research before publishing public opinion?
    Interesting.... I didn't know that "Hentai" Japan is SO popular in the world.
    But in a way, it is partly positve to Japan as it makes the country more mysterious.

    Mysteriousis Japan or Inscrutable Japan is not a new thing in the world, I think.
    And let it be unless it's harmful to Japan.
    Life is beach, not B**ch.
  5. #5
    SUX Vice-Admiral Male
    Join Date Aug 30, 2007
    Location Hungary or Scotland
    Posts 2,324
    Hungary
    Actual age of consent in Japan is regionally determined, not by a central body. This is the reason why it is misinterpreted. In Japan the age of consent is 13, in the individual regions it differs. It is simply a two-layer system. Both de facto and de jure the age of consent is NOT 13. If, say, an accession to Japan took place, an additional few square kilometres of water, for example, the default age of consent there would be 13.
  6. #6
    Japa'n vagyok Female
    Join Date Jan 18, 2006
    Location Nowhere - Now here
    Posts 3,541
    Japan-Tokyo
    Sorry, I seem to have mixed up two different "age of consent".

    1. Age of consent for sex is 13 years old.
    It does not differ by region, it's stipulated in 刑法 (kei-hou = Penal Code of Japan).
    Since under 児童福祉法 (jidou fukushi hou = Child Welfare Act of Japan), the definition of Child is under 18 years old, also the age of consent for marrige is 16 y.o (female) and 18 y.o. (male), age of consent for sex (13 years old) is not widely acknowledged.

    2. Age of consent for marrige is 16 years old for female and 18 years old for male.
    It is stipulated in 民法 (min-pou = Civil Code of Japan).

    What varies by region is a local law - act for sound upbringing of juveniles.
    I do not know the official term for such laws, it is 青少年健全育成条例 (seishounen kenzen ikusei jourei) in Japanese, its meaning is what I wrote in the above.
    Almost all the prefectures (except Nagano-ken) set this law, and it includes a clause forbidding anyone to do the act of obscenity to juveniles.
    Definition of "juvenile" here varies - some acts are based on Penal Code thus it is those under 13 years old, while other acts are based on Child Welfare Act which means those under 18 years old.
    Even the local acts stipulates the prevention of child (= under 13 years old) from abscenity, it does not mean it is commonly accepted to have sex with the 13 years olds.
  7. #7
    Male
    Join Date Aug 14, 2007
    Posts 67
    Belgium
    Wikipedia says :

    "The national age of consent in Japan is 13 as specified by the Japanese Penal Code Articles 176 and 177. However, prefectures can have ordinances that prohibit sexual activities with any minor under 18."

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ages_of..._in_Asia#Japan

    In Europe, only Spain has such a low age of consent. The average is 16.
    I like 美人ネス
  8. #8
    継続は力なり Male
    Join Date Apr 30, 2007
    Location 千葉県
    Posts 1,125
    Japan-Chiba
    Age of consent just means the age they can legally have sex with each other right? Say, a 13 and 15 year old have their first time. According to the law they can't get in trouble.

    I mean Japan doesn't actually permit men to have sex with girls who are 13 does it?
  9. #9
    Japa'n vagyok Female
    Join Date Jan 18, 2006
    Location Nowhere - Now here
    Posts 3,541
    Japan-Tokyo
    Age of consent just means the age they can legally have sex with each other right? Say, a 13 and 15 year old have their first time. According to the law they can't get in trouble.

    I mean Japan doesn't actually permit men to have sex with girls who are 13 does it?
    You're right, the answer is "no" because it's against Child Welfare Act.
  10. #10
    Rope Shrine Maiden Female
    Join Date Mar 5, 2007
    Location England
    Posts 1,570
    UK - England
    In all fairness, in places where the age of consent is higher, it's still not generally accepted. In Britain, the age of consent is 16 but that doesn't mean it's accepted for a 40 year old man to sleep with a 16 year old girl. Unfortunately, it does happen but, it's not against the law... just not a generally accepted thing. The man would be socially regarded as a pervert but legally, there's nothing wrong there.

    I just wonder where the article I mentioned got their 'Fact' from, and it makes me wonder if any of the other laws in it are true.
  11. #11
    後輩 Female
    Join Date Mar 3, 2010
    Location Andover
    Posts 5
    USA - Connecticut
    Sorry for the bump, but does anyone have a list of prefectures, or at least the original source of this law IN JAPANESE? Because there is a lot of disagreement on the internet about the actual age of consent and I can't find a trustworthy legal source (english wikipedia without a Japanese citation does not count ye fools...)
  12. #12
    禁漁期 Male
    Join Date Feb 22, 2008
    Location under the clear sky
    Posts 8,084
    Japan
    刑法 the penal code
    第二編 罪
    第二十二章 わいせつ、姦淫及び重婚の罪
    (強姦)
    第百七十七条  暴行又は脅迫を用いて十三歳以上の女子を姦淫した者は、強姦の罪とし、三年以上の有期懲役に処する。十三 歳未満の女子を姦淫した者も、同様とする。
    http://law.e-gov.go.jp/htmldata/M40/...00000000000000


    list of prefecture ordinances for the protection of young people
    都道府県別青少年健全育成条例
    http://seisyonen-laws.info/

    example: the case of Tokyo
    東京都青少年の健全な育成に関する条例
    第一章 総則
    (定義)
    第二条 この条例において、次の各号に掲げる用語の意義は、それぞれ当該各号に定めるところに よる。
    一 青少年 十八歳未満の者をいう。

    第三章の二 青少年の性に関する健全な判断能力の育成
    (青少年に対する反倫理的な性交等の禁止)
    第十八条の六 何人も、青少年とみだらな性交又は性交類似行為を行つてはならない。

    第五章 罰則
    (罰則)
    第二十四条の三 第十八条の六の規定に違反した者は、二年以下の懲役又は百万円以下の罰金に処 する。
    http://www.reiki.metro.tokyo.jp/reik...012150001.html
  13. #13
    先輩 Male
    Join Date Jul 6, 2011
    Location Somerset
    Posts 164
    United Kingdom
    I find the 16 for girls and 18 for guys quite suprising. Why is there a difference? If anything if a 2 year difference existed I would expect it to be the girls who had to be older as they are in essence a more ''vulnerable'' group. As a whole though most countries age of consent is screwed up. For example..
    Here in the UK it is 16. If a 16yr old guy and 15yr 9 month girl have sex the guy goes to prison. Yet in essence they really are the same age pretty much and as long as its consensual it shouldnt be a issue. Really only extreme ages are a problem.. 19yr old guy and 13yr old guy that is a bit dodgey... Age is less of a factor the older a person becomes another example..
    24 and 30 no issue at all is it? Theyve both been adults for ages but 20 and 14 instantly wrong because a 6 year gap is pretty wrong at that age.

    Age of consents are just fixed defaults because goverments dont have the time to access things on a case by case basis.
  14. #14
    一切皆苦 Male
    Join Date Jan 8, 2004
    Location ATL
    Posts 7,682
    United States
    In Tokyo-to the age of consent 18 for everyone. That's according to what Toritoribe posted above.
    Avoid Mojibake! -- 文字化けを避ける!
    Jim Breen's online dictionary and kanji lookup
    Dictionary at Goo -- English-Japanese, Japanese-English, Japanese Language
    Weblio -- Multiple Japanese dictionary and encyclopedia simultaneous lookup
    Lang-8 -- Have native speakers correct your writing!
  15. #15
    先輩 Female
    Join Date Nov 5, 2011
    Location Brisbane
    Posts 26
    Australia
    I believe (from what I learnt in Legal studies back in 2004 anyway o.O) that in Queensland/Australia its 16, but for more than a 2 year age gap both parties need to be over 18 (ie I think its slightly illegal for a 16 year old to have sex with a 19 year old - although not massively chased up although a 16 year old and a 40 year old probably would be) yet an 18 year old and a 40 year old is fine. I assume many places around the world would be similar? At least morally if not legally.

    I was always grossed out by love hotels when I was in Japan, but then learnt that many kids live with their parents well into their 30s thus its a bit of a requirement to get nookie without your parents busting in on you XD Still - I'll avoid visiting one regardless of how much I'm told of their hygiene standards XD
  16. #16
    Rope Shrine Maiden Female
    Join Date Mar 5, 2007
    Location England
    Posts 1,570
    UK - England
    Oh wow... imagine my surprise when I come back to this forum after 2 years and find an old thread of mine resurrected! Thanks for all of your contributions to this.

    I know what you mean about the love hotels, Mataeka. The idea kind of grosses me out too. I'd probably take a look, but I doubt I'd actually use one.
  17. #17
    後輩 Male
    Join Date Jan 2, 2012
    Location Nikkō, Tochigi
    Posts 11
    Japan
    I find it stupid to have the age of consent at 13 but all the prefectures have it between 16-18. While a 13 year old doesn't interest me in the slightest I do find the whole situation rather strange and confusing. Either have a nationwide AOC at 16,17 or 18 or make it better known like the american states do.
  18. #18
    先輩 Female
    Join Date Dec 14, 2011
    Location Osaka
    Posts 25
    Japan
    Why oh why would we have to consider love hotels or *RELATIVELY* low age of consent perverse?!

    I find the Japanese views and attitude to sex quite refreshing actually. We tend to judge it as perverse only because of the centuries of Christianism that equates sex with sin and guilt.
  19. #19
    Just me Male
    Join Date Aug 20, 2003
    Location Hokkaido, Japan (American)
    Posts 3,425
    Japan-Hokkaido
    I do find the whole situation rather strange and confusing. Either have a nationwide AOC at 16,17 or 18 or make it better known like the american states do.
    How can you really think it is "better known" in the US? Geez!

    I'm American, and I couldn't tell you what the AOC is for any state, let alone my home state! Taking a gander at what Wikipedia says doesn't make it any clearer. Let's just look at 2 states at random (yes, totally random, honest Injun). Emphasis is mine.

    WASHINGTON
    The age of consent in Washington is 16.

    It is also illegal to engage in sexual acts with someone younger than 18 under three different sets of circumstances, enumerated in RCW 9A.44.096. Foster parents with their foster children; school teachers and school administration employees over their students; The third set of circumstances require all of the following situations occur in tandem: The older person is 60 months or more older than the 16- or 17-year-old, the person is in a significant relationship as defined by RCW 9A.44.010, and such older person abuses the relationship to have sexual contact.

    Excuse me? Is there a manual for this somewhere? (What followed was a list of circumstances when there is a "close in age" factor! Even more confusing, eh?!

    PENNSYLVANIA
    The age of consent in Pennsylvania is 16 years of age for statutory sexual assault and 18 years for corruption of minors.

    Teenagers aged 13, 14 and 15 may or may not be able to legally engage in sexual activity with partners who are less than 4 years older. Such partners could not be prosecuted under statutory rape laws, but may be liable for other offenses, even when the sexual activity is consensual.
  20. #20
    Rope Shrine Maiden Female
    Join Date Mar 5, 2007
    Location England
    Posts 1,570
    UK - England
    "May or may nto be able to" wow... that's not very clear, is it? Is there a website where official laws are posted or anything? Wikipedia doesn't seem very reliable when it comes to this stuff.
  21. #21
    Resident Realist Male
    Join Date Aug 8, 2005
    Location All Over
    Posts 4,289
    USA - California
    What's refreshing about sex with a middle schooler?

    Why oh why would we have to consider love hotels or *RELATIVELY* low age of consent perverse?!

    I find the Japanese views and attitude to sex quite refreshing actually. We tend to judge it as perverse only because of the centuries of Christianism that equates sex with sin and guilt.
  22. #22
    先輩 Female
    Join Date Dec 14, 2011
    Location Osaka
    Posts 25
    Japan
    What's refreshing about sex with a middle schooler?
    Did I say "I find it refreshing to be able to have sex with a middle schooler"? => NO!

    I just don't mind middle schoolers having sex among themselves, in the sense that I don't think a law can prevent that, only education can. I was not not thinking of an adult having sex with a young teen, I mean who's the one with a twisted mind here?!?

    I think there must be laws protecting anyone and particularly young people from coerced sex, be it through force or authority. Laws regulating age differences between partners are a good start.
  23. #23
    Resident Realist Male
    Join Date Aug 8, 2005
    Location All Over
    Posts 4,289
    USA - California
    I find the Japanese views and attitude to sex quite refreshing actually. We tend to judge it as perverse only because of the centuries of Christianism that equates sex with sin and guilt.
    I assumed that you were referring to the
    *RELATIVELY* low age of consent
    you mentioned just before lumping the collective "we" together in your indictment of "Christianism" that is responsible for our puritanical views on sex.

    However, the "age of consent" is most commonly invoked in cases of statutory rape. In fact, the first recorded law regarding the age of consent was codified in British rape statutes. It's a law that's designed to keep minors from getting "corrupted," or as you say, coerced or forced into a sexual relationship before they're truly aware of what they're consenting to. So, it seemed that what you were patting Japan on the back for was its relatively loose protection of minors from sexual exploitation.

    I suggest you consider the topic and choose your words more carefully next time you decide to speak for the rest of us.
  24. #24
    後輩 Male
    Join Date Feb 19, 2012
    Location Rowlett
    Posts 7
    USA - Texas
    However, the "age of consent" is most commonly invoked in cases of statutory rape. In fact, the first recorded law regarding the age of consent was codified in British rape statutes. It's a law that's designed to keep minors from getting "corrupted," or as you say, coerced or forced into a sexual relationship before they're truly aware of what they're consenting to.
    I don't think that that is necessarily true, or else the term "jailbait" would not be common place. If these laws were used almost solely in cases where a young individual was forced or coerced, then no one would use the term "jailbait" to simply describe an attractive younger person. I've personally heard many accounts, both from the perspective of the older and younger individual, where someone is thrown in jail and labeled a sex offender when both parties involved thoroughly testify that it was 100 percent consensual. All it takes is 1 person who doesn't like the older individual to call the cops, and no amount of support or testifying from the younger individual will do anything. I'm not saying age of consent laws shouldn't exist, but there should be some sense in the way they are enforced, and there often isn't, at least in conserv-o-town America (I live in Texas).
  25. #25
    Just me Male
    Join Date Aug 20, 2003
    Location Hokkaido, Japan (American)
    Posts 3,425
    Japan-Hokkaido
    Who actually used the term jailbait in such an innocent way? Whoo-boy!
Page 1 of 2 12 Last
  • Jump to page:

Similar Threads

  1. Great DS Games for Learning Japanese!
    By Emoni in forum Learning Japanese
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: Jul 11, 2013, 03:59
  2. Japanese Speaking Football Job
    By BetRecruit in forum All Things Japanese
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: Sep 30, 2009, 18:43
  3. Some questions to ask about Japanese Religions.
    By cuonglhvt in forum All Things Japanese
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: Sep 1, 2009, 12:39
  4. Keeping up appearances- western fixation with Japanese beauty
    By Tokis-Phoenix in forum Chit Chat & Miscellaneous
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: Sep 3, 2008, 09:19

User Tag List

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

About JREF

JREF is a travel, language and study guide on all things Japanese, with a constantly growing travel section, a discussion forum, a section on Japanese language, a Japan gallery, a comprehensive directory, a Japan-related classifieds section and a place where you can find Japanese friends, pen pals, or more.
Copyright © 1999-2014 Japan Reference All Rights Reserved