Feedback Member Introduction Section

Discussion in 'Support, Feedback, FAQs' started by Mike Cash, Dec 13, 2017.

  1. Mike Cash

    Mike Cash 骨も命も皆此の土地に埋めよう

    16,416
    1,554
    273
    I've recently been reflecting on the phenomenon of people joining the site, making an introductory post....and then permanently disappearing into the ether. It happens so much it is not an exaggeration to say it is the norm. It must have the highest incidence of drive-by posters of any section on the site.

    Could we not get along just as well without it?
     
  2. Uncle Frank

    Uncle Frank SECURITY-you SPAM/we BAN
    Staff Member Admin

    10,167
    466
    154
    But that would end my 10 or twenty posts a year I get . Maybe we need male & female stripers to keep them coming back.
     
  3. thomas

    thomas Unswerving cyclist
    Admin

    8,503
    668
    224
    Thanks for your suggestion, Mike!

    Even though we encourage new members to introduce themselves by linking our welcome mail to the Membership section, only very few signups comply. I haven’t really compared the numbers, but most of the more active fora see their fair share of fly-by posting. Given the tiny trickle of members still posting at all I’m a bit reluctant to deprive them of that opportunity.

    In order to streamline the forum I’m thinking of merging the Community and the Member Introduction sections. Other inactive sections could be converted into subfora in order to take up less real estate on the forum index page. Of course, I’m open to suggestions.

    We might be in for a little clean-up before the New Year. :emoji_smile:
     
  4. Mike Cash

    Mike Cash 骨も命も皆此の土地に埋めよう

    16,416
    1,554
    273
    My suggestion would be to have a minimum post count requirement before anyone can start a thread in the Member Introduction section.

    It would eliminate the pointless and useless threads from people who never say anything again after introducing themselves. If that's all they were going to do then I'd just as soon not hear from them in the first place.
     
  5. nice gaijin

    nice gaijin Resident Realist
    Moderator

    5,154
    332
    157
    if they don't have an apparent home, those posts may spill out elsewhere. I don't mind the idea of making a minimum post requirement to make new threads, if we can specifically tell users trying to create their introduction thread that they must first participate in some other discussions, then they can create an intro thread...

    This may have some unintended consequences on user behavior. I personally don't really reference the member intros unless I'm interested in knowing more about a member I'm unfamiliar with.. so this issue doesn't really affect me.

    If the member threads bother you and you aren't the kind to respond to lots of them and roll out the welcome mat for people (sorry, I don't do this kind of thing anymore), you can hide the member intro sub-forum from showing up when you search for "New Posts"
     
  6. thomas

    thomas Unswerving cyclist
    Admin

    8,503
    668
    224
    Update - Forum cleanup | Japan Forum

    I'll think about the minimum post requirement for the Community section. If I remember correctly, in vBulletin the Member Lounge could only be accessed by senior members.
     
  7. Weegee

    Weegee Registered

    3
    0
    1
    Well, I'm the opposite. I have been on hundreds of forums since 1998nand never introduce myself. I just join in and look at all the forums as one big family. But since JREF keeps pestering me for an intro I will do it.
     
  8. mdchachi

    mdchachi Moderator
    Moderator

    2,174
    195
    87
    My working assumption has been that any new content is good for you. Even if the member never posts again, that is one more post that is picked up by search engines, potentially shows up in search results, potential ad impressions and potentially clicked on by someone earning you 1 yen or whatever it may be to pay for your costs and, hopefully, beer money or more. If that's correct, then it's not helpful to add barriers to new "content."
     
  9. Mike Cash

    Mike Cash 骨も命も皆此の土地に埋めよう

    16,416
    1,554
    273
    Then we should allow spambots.....
     
  10. mdchachi

    mdchachi Moderator
    Moderator

    2,174
    195
    87
    That goes against the TOS, for obvious reasons.
     
  11. thomas

    thomas Unswerving cyclist
    Admin

    8,503
    668
    224
    Some people introduce themselves, some don't. Generally, introductions are seen as a friendly gesture towards the community. I agree that if you have no intention to stay and contribute, they don't make a lot of sense.

    Anyhow, as we don't intend to pester new members I've done away with the pop-up notice.
     

Share this page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice